The Future of the Big Three – Part Two
July 2nd, 2008
GM, Ford and Chrysler represent to a large degree the Industrial Age legacy of manufacturing in the U.S. “What was good for General Motors was good for the United States” was, for decades in the 20th century a very true statement. The manufacturing might of America post WWII was an economic miracle and the apotheosis of the Industrial Age. Supported by the explosive growth of television and the American advertising business, the consumer market of wondrous new goods exploded. The Big Three auto companies rode this wave to unprecedented success.
Every year, there were the exciting new model introductions of all the auto makes in the Fall. Families became conditioned to buying new cars every few years just to keep up with the styling – and their neighbors.. Planned obsolescence was part of the business plan of the U.S. auto industry. The oil embargo of 1973-74 was a major hiccup and it provided a market opportunity for Japanese auto makers to enter the market with small cars that provided higher MPG than those provided by the Big Three. Once the price of oil collapsed after the Iranian revolution the next two decades of cheap oil allowed the Big Three to manufacture ever bigger SUVs and trucks which they sold the American public with their powerful marketing efforts.
The problem was that the leadership of the Big Three never adjusted to the post-9/11 world. Oil has increased in price by 1400% since 1998 and 700% since 2001, yet the Detroit auto makers continued to focus on the profits to be made from ever larger gas guzzling vehicles. This helped to increase the dependency on foreign oil, which of course for geopolitical and financial reasons was not a good thing for the country. What was good for the Big Three was no longer good for America.
What can the Big Three do? How can that phrase “What is good for General Motors (and Ford and Chrysler) is good for America” again become true? What is the real business the Detroit automakers need to be in now that we are closing in on the end of the first decade of this century? How can these companies avoid bankruptcy and again become profitable and become aligned with the future of America?
The Big Three need to make a complete transition from planned obsolescence and new model thinking to sustainability.
Redefine the word ‘performance’ from speed and acceleration and horsepower to fuel efficiency and cost of operation. Concept cars should no longer be like race cars but rather cars that support this new definition of performance such as cars covered with solar panels
The Big Three need to fully understand that the world is now starting to pass through Peak Oil and therefore the price of oil will remain above $100 a barrel for the foreseeable future. This forecaster thinks that $200 barrel oil will be a reality occasionally, if not permanently in the years ahead. The ‘good old days’ of the car business, powered by cheap gas are over – forever!
The goal should be a fleet average of 50 MPG within 5 years. This means two things immediately: an immediate retooling of gasoline/hybrid autos to dramatically increase fuel efficiency and making the electric car a mass product. For example, if the Chevrolet Volt were available for sale today, and at a relatively affordable price, dealers could not keep it in stock. Aim for a million electric vehicle sales per year as soon as possible
Small is the new big. This will be true until electric and hydrogen powered cars become so cheap to drive that size creep may kick back in. The Smart Car is basically sold out in 2008, its first year of sales in the U.S. Learn from this and compete against it.
Change not only the fuel source but the materials. Move from ‘big iron’ to ‘light graphite’ and other new composite materials that are both lighter and stronger than steel and aluminum.
Develop partnerships with power companies and high tech companies to recast the American transportation landscape. In the 20th century oil companies supported Detroit automakers with filling stations across the country. Now, and in the decades ahead there needs to be recharging stations that can rapidly recharge electric batteries and hydrogen fuel cells. This is the vast new market that will provide unparalleled wealth for the companies and individuals that help make this happen.
What is good for America is energy independence. What is good for America is again setting an example for the world to follow in terms of transportation for this century. What is good for America and humanity is lowering greenhouse emissions by 50-75% as soon as possible and the dramatic decrease in use of fossil fuels. What will be good for the Big Three is to align with what is good for America. Alignment and leadership or bankruptcy and failure. The fork in the road is now. Or rather drive on the freeway to the future or take the next exit and get off.
July 6th, 2008 at 10:03 am
You really don’t know what you’re talking about. GM doesn’t have any money to develop innovative new models because GM is basically a health care company that makes cars at a loss. until that’s fixed say good bye.
July 8th, 2008 at 1:34 pm
Couldn’t be better said.
One question is whose stock would a 25 year old decide
to invest in..GM or Ford or one of the new start ups
that aim for highy fuel efficient cars on our roads.
It is truly a fork in the road extremely burdened by
the culture and legacy that the big three carry as baggage. If any of them can deposit that baggage, and move forward there may be no better investment than another century for the Big Three (Two..One) Only they,
(and foreign giants) and not start ups can produce the millions of cars that will replace the current fleet.
July 14th, 2008 at 1:28 pm
ha, the leaders of the big three never adjusted to the post-1972 world, or whenever those long line were
July 23rd, 2008 at 8:57 am
Ok, so I work for GM. A health care company that has no money? Sorry, but have you noticed the huge advancements in health care cost sharing lately? And even with the latest announcement on cost cuts, we haven’t trimmed the essential technology investments David refers to. It is our future. We have hybrids. We have alternative fuel vehicles. We have more cars that get over 30 mpg than anyone. And we are leading the way to the electrification of the auto. Don’t believe me? Just watch.
July 31st, 2008 at 12:36 pm
[…] I wrote about the Big Three Auto companies and how they need to change, and change their product lines if they wanted to stay “big”.  Since those columns […]
August 18th, 2008 at 1:45 pm
[…] vehicles, which is probably known to everybody by now. David Houle has more to say about The Future of the Big Three. If they have one. Here’s a look at their performance on the stockmarket since 1970 (via […]